Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries 2026

7.4

IMDB

2026 , Mystery

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

Cast:

Galadriel Stineman
Denise Gossett
Kevin Joy
Lance E. Nichols
Ryan O'Quinn

Remove From Watch Later Add To Watch Later

Remove From Favourites Add To Favourites

You may also like:

7.1/10

2023

The Killing Vote

7.6/10

2023

Club Hooligans

7/10

2023

HeartBeat

7.6/10

2023

Miraculous Brothers

6.7/10

2023

FreeKs

7.6/10

2021

HIP - High Intellectual Potential

7.6/10

2023

Undead Murder Farce

7/10

2023

A Murder at the End of the World

6.6/10

2023

Burn the House Down

6.3/10

2023

Full Circle

7.4/10

2023

Celebrity

7.7/10

2021

Calls

7.3/10

2021

Tell Me Your Secrets

6.5/10

2022

Off Season

7.3/10

2023

My Lovely Liar

7.5/10

1999

Beck

7.7/10

2023

The Lost Flowers of Alice Hart

6.5/10

2022

Close to Home: Murder in the Coalfield

8.9/10

2023

My Dearest

7.6/10

2020

Breathe: Into the Shadows

8.4/10

2023

Moving

6.1/10

2016

Un planeta extraño

6.1/10

2020

Outlier

6.8/10

2023

Found

8.5/10

2021

LINK CLICK

7.4/10

2020

Murder on Middle Beach

8.1/10

2023

The Kidnapping Day

7/10

2022

Mai: A Mother's Rage

6.8/10

2023

The Other Black Girl

6.8/10

2023

The Three Detectives

6.7/10

2023

Burning Body

7.3/10

2023

Dear Child

6.6/10

2023

Harlan Coben's Shelter

7.8/10

2023

Witness to Murder: Digital Evidence

7.3/10

2023

Mask Girl

7.2/10

2023

The Woman in the Wall

Message successfully sent. We will take a look.

sending data

CONTACT US

Please fill all fields.

Subject is required

Valid email required

Required minimum 5 symbols